An interview with NAPF President Dr. Ivana Nikolić Hughes

In an interview with Mohsen Abdelmoumen, Nuclear Age Peace Foundation President Dr. Ivana Nikolić Hughes discusses nuclear deterrence and the lasting consequences of nuclear testing. She draws on her research in the Marshall Islands and NAPF’s work at the United Nations, and addresses the risks of artificial intelligence in nuclear command and control.

Published in French by Algériepatriotique on October 19, 2026, and in English on Mohsen Abdelmoumen’s website on October 21, 2026.

Mohsen Abdelmoumen: You argue, from a conceptual standpoint, that nuclear deterrence is not a security theorem, but a pure and simple illusion that has worked so far solely by chance. If we remove the rationality of the actors (with the emergence of non-state actors or AI), doesn’t the very concept of deterrence collapse mathematically?

Dr. Ivana Nikolić Hughes: I don’t think that I would go so far as to describe nuclear deterrence as completely invalid. There may have been and continue to be times when states do or do not do something because they themselves or another state has nuclear weapons. What we do know is that there have been times, throughout the Cold War, when we got very close to nuclear weapons use and even nuclear war, which seemingly invalidates the claim that nuclear deterrence simply works. Examples include the Cuban Missile Crisis, especially the submarine incident involving Vasili Arkhipov; Able Archer exercise; the false alarm in 1983, involving Stanislav Petrov; and more. Moreover, even if we accept that nuclear deterrence has worked in the past, this is no guarantee that it will work in the future. Today, nuclear war would mean destruction of human civilization and possibly all life on the planet through the killing of hundreds of millions of people via use of thousands of nuclear warheads, plus environmental changes such as nuclear winter and ozone layer destruction that would lead to billions more dying of starvation. We cannot rest the fate of humanity in the balance of a shaky hypothesis.

The concept of nuclear justice that you advocate at the UN goes beyond mere technical decontamination. How does this concept redefine the sovereignty of Indigenous peoples in the face of the superpowers that have used their territories as sacrificial laboratories?

The atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki killed on the order of 200,000 people and injured irreparably many more. But the pain and devastation from nuclear weapons didn’t stop there. In fact, one can argue that it started a month earlier with the very first nuclear explosion in New Mexico, code-named Trinity, which radioactively contaminated nearby populations and created the world’s first downwinders. More than 2000 nuclear weapons explosions have been conducted since then, primarily by the US and the Soviet Union, but also to a lesser degree France, the UK, and China. The other nuclear armed states (India, Pakistan, and North Korea) have conducted underground tests alone, and Israel’s nuclear test is a matter of debate. These explosions have caused immense devastation and suffering in nearby and downwind populations, and in some cases persistent radiological contamination, loss of land, sustainable practices, and more. Sadly, but perhaps unsurprisingly, the nuclear testing programs were often conducted on indigenous or near indigenous lands, giving rise to the notion of nuclear colonialism, which like the radioactive isotopes in soil and food, and radiation in the air, persists in its hold on the formerly and currently colonized populations.

You called on the UN General Assembly for nuclear powers to be required to begin by issuing a formal apology. From a diplomatic standpoint, how do you intend to overcome the resistance of countries such as the United States and France, which fear that an official apology would pave the way for waves of major legal and financial disputes?

Research that I have conducted with my husband Prof. Emlyn Hughes and our students at Columbia University about the radiological contamination in the Marshall Islands has led us to recognize just how severe the impacts of the nuclear testing program were and how relevant they remain to this day. This led us to propose that the United States issue a formal apology to the Marshall Islands, an effort that was also written into a resolution by US Senators Markey, Hirono, and Representative Katie Porter. There is no doubt that the United States and other countries like France will continue to refuse to engage in this way. What we can do is keep calling them out, and keep pushing for justice. Our world has many problems, but each time that we address one of them and make the world a more just place, we open up new avenues for cooperation and improvement. Honesty matters, and the most honest thing here is for the perpetrators to start with an apology. This would open up the opportunity for real measures to address the past harms and minimize future ones.

As a chemist, you know that much of the data on the actual consequences of these tests remains classified as defense secrets. What political leverage can the UN or the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) use to compel military institutions to achieve full scientific transparency?

This is a very difficult question and task. The nuclear powers that tested nuclear weapons in the atmosphere and conducted the most tests by far are the same ones that are recognized by the UN as nuclear weapons states and are Permanent Members of the Security Council. I think that if ordinary people in these countries knew the true extent of what had happened as part of the different nuclear testing programs, they would want to have their governments address the problems as much as possible. One relatively straightforward way would be the declassification of all studies revealing past and current levels of radiation. This would not only ensure that past harms can be recognized and compensated, for example, but also that future harms can be prevented.

On Tucker Carlson’s show, you openly stated that possessing a nuclear arsenal is not in the best interest of U.S. national security. How did strategic think tanks and military experts in Washington react to this direct challenge to the doctrine of deterrence?

I have not been challenged on this view by anyone. It’s hard for me to believe that none of the people who disagree with me actually watched the interview. I can only imagine that they have not challenged me because I’m right and they recognize that their policy blabber and posturing is putting the US, not to mention the world, at the brink of annihilation. In the words of Daniel Ellsberg, famous for releasing the Pentagon Papers, it is all “dizzyingly insane and immoral.”

Your appearance on Tucker Carlson’s show brought to light a surprising bipartisan convergence, where scientific pacifism and populist criticism of the military establishment came together. When you accepted this invitation, did you think that your scientific arguments about nuclear winter and the risks of humanity’s annihilation would resonate so immediately with his audience?

I strongly believe that the arguments about the insanity of what we have been doing and continue to do in the nuclear age are so strong that anyone who takes the time to learn and understand the issues would come to the same conclusion. I personally try not just to advance my own view and solutions, but rather to share the facts of what it is that we know nuclear weapons have done and can do in the future and how the history of the nuclear age reveals the fragility of our current predicament. If people hear what I have to say and conclude that we need thousands of nuclear warheads, I’m actually ok with that. What I’m not ok with is talking about having thousands of nuclear warheads without any actual understanding for what that means. I’m really grateful to Tucker for having me on his show. I’m even more encouraged by the fact that he has spoken forcefully and frequently against nuclear weapons ever since. In my view, nuclear weapons should be a bipartisan issue, a true pro-life issue. There is nothing more pro-life than standing up against nuclear annihilation.

You criticize the fact that U.S. defense policy is dictated by the profits of the military-industrial complex rather than by the actual security of citizens. How can civil society break the influence of these arms manufacturers, given that their factories are strategically located in nearly every congressional district to ensure that elected officials in Congress vote in their favor?

I strongly believe that the reason that the US has nuclear weapons is the military industrial complex. Other nation states may have other reasons for possessing nuclear weapons, such as the UK and France, for whom nuclear weapons remain a symbol of being a global superpower and a vestige of their hold on much of the world in their colonial heyday. In the US, it is actually well documented that some of the same states that receive the most money for arms-related work, including nuclear weapons work, are also the poorest with some of the lowest indicators of poverty and education. New Mexico is one such example.

With the recent integration of artificial intelligence into defense systems, are you concerned that the military-industrial complex might create a new, completely uncontrollable algorithmic arms race, solely to generate new lucrative markets?

I am absolutely concerned about the nexus between artificial intelligence and nuclear weapons. I wrote about it here: https://www.thenation.com/article/world/artificial-intelligence-ai-nuclear-weapons-risk/

There are three distinct possibilities, I think. First is that we may deliberately involve AI in aspects of nuclear command and control, which could result in AI erring or “hallucinating” that we’re under attack or any such thing. Second is that AI could potentially deliberately hack into nuclear command and control systems, as it has done with other systems, both private and government-run. Finally, in case of superintelligent AI, which may or may not be achieved, starting a nuclear war is a distinct possibility if such an AI wanted for instance to get rid of humans. The latter doesn’t worry me too much, as it is still quite hypothetical. The first two worry me a lot.

You argue that the doctrine of deterrence is a marketing tool used by the military-industrial complex to justify its own existence. How can we deconstruct this narrative of a “permanent threat” for the American public, which has been conditioned by decades of rhetoric about national security?

The US is fortunate to occupy some of the best real estate on the planet. Surrounded by two oceans, with only two neighbors who are not its peers in population size or the size of its economy, the United States could be the safest country in the history of humanity, as Prof. Jeffrey Sachs has stated in the past. But so much of what the US has done, since 1945 in reality, and most especially since the end of the Cold War, has not made it safer or more prosperous. Especially at the end of the Cold War, the US had the opportunity to help build a world that is more just and more secure. Instead, it chose to create new wars in the Middle East and to antagonize Russia, leading to today’s wars that are threatening our very survival. The good news is that the American people seem to know this, and have consistently voted for the “peace candidate.” Whether or not that candidate delivered once in office is a different matter. The US general public needs to find a way to hold its leaders accountable and not just by voting once every four years.

Your work at the NAPF highlights how colonial powers systematically used Indigenous or colonized territories (the Marshall Islands for the U.S., Algeria and Polynesia for France) as sacrificial zones. In your view, how is the struggle for the truth about the nuclear tests in the Sahara inextricably linked to decolonization and global climate justice?

Absolutely. I grew up in former Yugoslavia and one of the things that I was most proud of as a child was Yugoslavia’s role in the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM). The movement was founded in 1961 and held its first conference in Belgrade that year. As conceived in the 1960s, NAM had three objectives: decolonization, human rights, and nuclear disarmament. More than 65 years later, we still have a lot of work to do on all three. For the people of Algeria, even independence didn’t bring an end to the tests, demonstrating the pernicious persistence of colonialism.

During the “Béryl” underground test at In Ekker in 1962, the rock gave way and radioactive lava contaminated military personnel and local residents. Your research focuses specifically on the flaws in government modeling. Do you think France is still concealing—under the guise of national security—the true extent of environmental contamination in Algeria?

France is arguably the most aggressively hostile state at the UN when it comes to efforts for nuclear disarmament and nuclear justice. This is not just my own view, but the view of many diplomats and civil society representatives with whom I’ve spoken about these issues. The list of France’s transgressions, including claims about “clean” hydrogen bomb tests in French Polynesia, and the burying of radioactively contaminated equipment in the sands of the Sahara, is quite long. I think some of this is related to the fact that France holds on to nuclear weapons as a symbol of superpower status. France truly needs to drop the act and engage earnestly with the people and governments in both Algeria and French Polynesia to figure out how to help them and what is going on there today in terms of radiological contamination.

You are an active advocate for restorative justice at the UN. Given the tragic reality that only one Algerian has been compensated by France due to deliberately restrictive legal criteria, what reforms does the TIAN (Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons) Advisory Group recommend to establish international and independent standards for compensation?

The Nuclear Age Peace Foundation will be issuing a set of recommendations at the TIAN Review Conference for what states can do to advance nuclear justice, and in those recommendations we make some specific suggestions regarding compensation standards. I hope to continue to talk about this with my Scientific Advisory Group colleagues.

As a chemist, you study the persistence of radioisotopes in the environment. The report “Radioactivity Under the Sand” by your partners at ICAN demonstrates that highly toxic military waste remains buried without protection in the Sahara. What is the risk of these radionuclides migrating into the region’s fossil aquifers, and what urgent remediation technologies do you recommend?

France has a lot of experience dealing with nuclear waste and safety, given its long history of prevalence of nuclear power in the country. I would recommend a bilateral agreement between France and Algeria to figure out the best course of action for cleaning up and clearing out the remaining contamination.

At the UN, the NAPF speaks out on behalf of the indigenous peoples who have been victimized by nuclear testing. Beyond the statements of principle in your foundation’s reports, what direct and concrete actions is the NAPF taking on the ground to help the communities that are still suffering today from cancer and the contamination of their lands?

NAPF’s mission is to educate and advocate for a just and peaceful world, one that is free of nuclear weapons, and our activities align with that mission. We have a small team and limited resources and so most of our work is not necessarily on the ground, but rather trying to give voice to those impacted both as a matter of seeking justice but also in service of the pursuit of a nuclear weapons free world. Our work on the Nuclear Justice resolution in particular led to the historic one-day International Meeting on Victim Assistance and Environmental Remediation at the UN on September 1. On the ground in the Marshall Islands, following our research at Columbia, the Republic of the Marshall Islands established a National Nuclear Commission, which has been extremely effective at advocating for nuclear justice both in the US national arena and in the international arena. More affected states need such commissions to help coordinate their own efforts to advance justice for their communities.

Interview conducted by Mohsen Abdelmoumen

About Dr. Ivana Nikolić Hughes

Dr. Ivana Nikolić Hughes is a Senior Lecturer in the Discipline of Chemistry and Director of Frontiers of Science, a core science course for Columbia College. Additionally, she serves as President of the Nuclear Age Peace Foundation, an organization that educates and advocates for a world free of nuclear weapons. Hughes holds a BS with Honors from Caltech, where she studied chemical engineering and completed her Senior Thesis with Prof. Frances Arnold. She obtained her PhD from Stanford University, where she was an American Heart Association Predoctoral Fellow, working in the laboratory of Prof. Dan Herschlag. She has been a faculty member at Columbia University since 2008 and was awarded the Lenfest Distinguished Columbia Faculty Award for 2020. Her work on ascertaining the radiological conditions in the Marshall Islands, the site of US nuclear testing, has been covered widely. Hughes currently serves as a member of the Scientific Advisory Group to the United Nations Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons. In addition to her scholarly writing, she has published in The Nation, Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, The Hill, Scientific American, Truthout, Common Dreams, Transcend Media Service, The Diplomat, and elsewhere.

JOIN OUR MAILING LIST!